The Problem
Google/Nest is intentionally blocking older Generation 1 and Generation 2 thermostats from accessing their API servers, even though these devices are fully functional and use the exact same API structure as newer models.How the Blocking Works
Google’s blocking mechanism is surprisingly simple and arbitrary. When a Nest device connects to their API, it sends a model identifier (e.g.,Display-2.8 for Gen 2, Display-3.7 for Gen 3). Based solely on this identifier, Google’s servers return different responses:
Gen 1 & Gen 2 Response (Blocked)
czfe_url, ping_url, passphrase_url, transport_url) are empty strings. Without these URLs, the thermostat cannot communicate with the API to function properly.
Gen 3 Response (Working)
Display-2.8 to Display-3.7, all the URLs magically appear. The API structure is identical, the protocol is the same, and the hardware is capable - Google is simply blocking older devices by checking the model string.
Key Findings
Identical API Structure
Gen 1, Gen 2, and Gen 3 devices use the exact same API endpoints and protocol. There are no technical differences in how they communicate.
Arbitrary Blocking
Google blocks devices based solely on the model identifier, not on any actual technical limitation or incompatibility.
Telemetry Still Works
Interestingly, the
upload_url for logging is still provided to blocked devices. Google continues collecting telemetry data from Gen 1 & Gen 2 devices even while blocking their core functionality.Planned Obsolescence
This is a clear case of artificial obsolescence - perfectly functional hardware being intentionally disabled to push users toward newer products.
Why No Longer Evil Exists
What Can You Do?
Check Compatibility
Verify your Nest Thermostat generation and learn how to identify your device
Get Started
Choose between hosted service (easy) or self-hosted (advanced) setup
Questions? Join our Discord community or check out the FAQ for more information.